Groups Similar Look up By Text Browse About



Similar articles
Article Id Title Prob Score Similar Compare
215757 THEVERGE 2021-9-8:
Fraud, or just a failure? Theranos founder Elizabeth Holmes’s trial opening arguments
1.000 Find similar Compare side-by-side
215645 ARSTECHNICA 2021-9-8:
“Failure is not a crime,” Theranos founder’s lawyers tell jury
0.970 0.602 Find similar Compare side-by-side
215413 ARSTECHNICA 2021-9-5:
Investor overconfidence linked to selective memory
0.367 Find similar Compare side-by-side
215646 ARSTECHNICA 2021-9-8:
Fusion startup builds 10-foot-high, 20-tesla superconducting magnet
0.325 Find similar Compare side-by-side
215468 ARSTECHNICA 2021-9-7:
Forced use of horse dewormer on COVID patient overturned by Ohio judge
0.299 Find similar Compare side-by-side
215631 ARSTECHNICA 2021-9-10:
Ivermectin overdose death probed in NM: “I don’t want more people to die”
0.277 Find similar Compare side-by-side
215428 ARSTECHNICA 2021-9-6:
The quiet search for dark matter deep underground
0.272 Find similar Compare side-by-side
215584 ZDNET 2021-9-5:
If you want to understand how tech is changing, you need to follow the money
0.269 Find similar Compare side-by-side
215632 VENTUREBEAT 2021-9-9:
Notion’s COO: Why changing stock prices or valuations don’t necessarily reflect the full value you’re creating
0.268 Find similar Compare side-by-side
215720 ZDNET 2021-9-10:
US military reservist lands himself prison sentence for operating romance scams
0.268 Find similar Compare side-by-side
215616 ZDNET 2021-9-9:
Phishing attacks: One in three suspect emails reported by employees really are malicious
0.263 Find similar Compare side-by-side
215790 TECHREPUBLIC 2021-9-9:
The consumerization of dialysis at home
0.258 Find similar Compare side-by-side
215426 ARSTECHNICA 2021-9-6:
Life is Strange: True Colors hands-on preview: Not afraid to make you sad
0.255 Find similar Compare side-by-side
216070 ZDNET 2021-9-11:
American Airlines just made a sneaky decision that may appall customers
0.254 Find similar Compare side-by-side
215529 ZDNET 2021-9-7:
Watch out for digital Hurricane Ida scams: SEC
0.251 Find similar Compare side-by-side
215704 THEVERGE 2021-9-9:
Vape receipts help DOJ nab man who allegedly botnetted thousands of passwords
0.247 Find similar Compare side-by-side
215804 TECHREPUBLIC 2021-9-8:
Leadership tips: How to stay focused and craft a happier worldview
0.247 Find similar Compare side-by-side
215621 VENTUREBEAT 2021-9-10:
DeepMind aims to marry deep learning and classic algorithms
0.240 Find similar Compare side-by-side
215493 TECHREPUBLIC 2021-9-7:
Study: The "robots are coming to take our jobs" worry is overblown
0.236 Find similar Compare side-by-side
215563 ZDNET 2021-9-5:
Microsoft annoyed me for a year and still tells me to grin and bear it
0.235 Find similar Compare side-by-side
215602 ZDNET 2021-9-7:
UiPath fiscal Q2 results top expectations, raises recurring revenue view
0.234 Find similar Compare side-by-side
215718 ZDNET 2021-9-10:
Ukrainian man extradited to the US to face botnet, data theft charges
0.234 Find similar Compare side-by-side
215692 ARSTECHNICA 2021-9-9:
Recycling symbol can’t appear on non-recyclable items, California bill says
0.233 Find similar Compare side-by-side
215535 ZDNET 2021-9-7:
Best cloud migration service 2021
0.229 Find similar Compare side-by-side
215740 THEVERGE 2021-9-10:
Xiaomi promises its 120W fast charger won’t kill its new phone’s battery
0.228 Find similar Compare side-by-side

1

ID: 215757

URL: https://www.theverge.com/2021/9/8/22663723/theranos-elizabeth-holmes-trial-opening-arguments-day-one

Date: 2021-09-08

Fraud, or just a failure? Theranos founder Elizabeth Holmes’s trial opening arguments

Would you rather be a failure or a fraud? Judging by the opening statements in Elizabeth Holmes wire fraud trial, those seem to be Holmes options. Heres Robert Leach, assistant U.S. attorney, who is prosecuting the case against Holmes: This is a case about fraud, about lying and cheating to get money, Leach says. Thats a crime on Main Street and a crime in Silicon Valley. But according to Lance Wade, Holmes attorney, Holmes is just another failed startup leader: In the end, Theranos failed. And Ms. Holmes walked away with nothing. But failure is not a crime. Now, by the time the first day of the trial ended, the first witness had only just been introduced. There are plenty more witnesses and apparently just a whole fuckload of documents ahead of us. But my impression is that the prosecution is going to have an uphill battle to show Holmes intent to deceive, a crucial part of the case. According to the government, Theranos didnt start life as a fraud, so thats nice. Instead, in 2009, Holmes was rapidly running out of money. Worse, things with its pharma partners werent going so well — Pfizer and Schering-Plough, two huge drug companies, had cut it loose. Theranos was having a hard time making payroll. Out of time and out of money, Elizabeth Holmes decided to lie, Leach said. So Holmes started seeking investments, making the kind of grandiose startup claims were all familiar with from the tech industry. (Theranos was a medical company, but never mind.) Holmes gave revenue projections to Safeway that overestimated what Theranos could achieve, and gave Walgreens a report that suggested Pfizer had endorsed their tech. Leachs allegations about a Pfizer memo that had been shown to investors were astonishing. See, according to him, it was forged. Pfizers letterhead might have been on the memo but Pfizer didnt put it there. I expect well be hearing from Pfizer about this. Other allegations from Leach included that Holmes misled investors about Theranos relationship with the military — claiming that the companys mini analyzer was deployed in military helicopters, and saving lives, when its only relationship with the military was a small 2010 study at the Army burn center in Texas. According to Leach, Holmes also deceived investors about the readiness of the analyzer. And! Despite having zero revenue in 2012 and 2013, Holmes went around telling investors that revenue would be $140 million in 2014. (It was actually $150,000.) Were going to be hearing from some former Theranos employees who tried to tell Holmes and Balwani that the analyzers werent working as promised. One of them was fired. The other was ignored. And when Holmes own brother, who shed hired, told her that Theranos pregnancy tests had problems, she ignored him. Leach promised the jury would see email after email showing that Holmes was aware of the problems — but unlike the Pfizer memo, we didnt see any specific emails. And Elizabeth Holmes media persona made an appearance as well. According to Leach, favorable press coverage was a major way that Holmes was able to raise money — saying she approved this glowing WSJ piece and timed up a press release with it meant to lure investors. He also said that this Fortune article contained lies. But those pieces do contain some truths, Leach said. Holmes was in full control of Theranos. She owned it, she controlled it, the buck stopped with her, Leach said. She sweated the details. She was in charge. While the prosecution was specific, the defense was playing for sympathy. Wade opened by telling us about Holmes packing up her belongings into her car after Theranos went under. Then he took us back in time to Holmes dropping out of college at 19, after patenting a miniaturized system that would perform tests and give a result. According to Wade, Holmes co-defendant who is being tried separately, Sunny Balwani, encouraged her to drop out. Trusting and relying on Balwani as her primary advisor was one of her mistakes, Wade says. In Wades telling, Holmes was a wide-eyed naif — and nothing was really her fault. See, Balwani was responsible for the clinical labs where things were going wrong for patients, and financial modeling was also his job. Walgreens and Safeway pressured Holmes into marketing herself. So, at the suggestion of a board member, she hired marketing firm Chiat Day. (Not much mention was made of Elizabeth Holmes, Girl Genius, thought we did see an ad about Theranos inexpensive testing.) Also, Walgreens pushed Holmes into agreeing to a phased approach to testing — Theranos hadnt duped it into thinking it was using its own machines. Oh, and the inaccurate results? Sure, that can happen in any lab, Wade said. Holmes believed the tests were accurate and reliable and used them herself, as well as recommending them to her family. Balwani had oversight of the labs, and besides, the lab directors are legally responsible for safe and accurate testing, not Holmes. Some of those lab directors are going to testify and I am very interested to hear what they have to say! And although two years worth of Theranos tests were thrown out, Wade argued that well be hearing from only 20 patients and doctors who got bad results — when 8 million tests were performed. (Wade did not bring up the tests that had been voided.) Just 20 out of 8 million is an awfully small number of inaccurate tests, Wade said. He even did some showy math for the jury: thats 0.00025 percent of all tests. This suggests that Theranoss tests were actually very accurate and that the prosecution is cherry-picking — but it leaves out those voided tests. That is an enormous omission! As further evidence that Holmes believed in Theranos, Wade announced that Holmes hadnt sold any of her shares. She passed on every opportunity to sell, he said. She could have made hundreds of millions of dollars, but she was in it for the mission, not money, he said. Now, its kind of hard to sell shares of a private company — not impossible! — but I dont know what kind of agreements might have been in place about her ownership stake. After the omission about the two years worth of tests getting shitcanned, I dont buy much of what Wade is selling. What else is he leaving out? If Wade is to be believed, Holmes is responsible for almost nothing. She was young, after all, and a college dropout. She worked seven days a week at Theranos but somehow could not possibly be responsible for anything except her dream of success. And while Wade hinted at the abuse allegations Holmes made about Balwani — he sometimes had a temper, could lash out, did not always treat people kindly and in Holmes relationship with him, there was another side to it that most people never saw — he never directly argued that abuse was a factor in Holmes actions. Im guessing this is because having Holmes take the stand is a risky move, and if the case hangs on the abuse allegations, shell have to testify to the abuse. After all, most people didnt even know the two of them were in a relationship. This trial is just beginning, and a lot hinges on the testimony we havent yet heard and emails we havent yet seen. But the outlines of the story each side is telling are clear. For the prosecution, proving that Holmes isnt a dimwitted figurehead might be tough — the standard, after all, is beyond a reasonable doubt, and Wade hammered hard on the presumption of innocence. Okay. But with so much blame being shifted to Balwani, the question arises: if the defense really wants to argue this is merely the story of failure due to naïveté, then what exactly was Elizabeth Holmes doing at Theranos? She was apparently breaking her back there every day for fifteen years! Wade suggested she was primarily working on the tests and making bad decisions, but surely if that were all she was doing, she probably could have taken some weekends off.