Groups Similar Look up By Text Browse About



Similar articles
Article Id Title Prob Score Similar Compare
121876 TECHCRUNCH 2019-2-14:
Did New York lose anything with Amazon’s rejection? It’s complicated.
1.000 Find similar Compare side-by-side
121567 VENTUREBEAT 2019-2-13:
Heartland Tech Weekly: Why Amazon won’t drop its New York expansion plans
0.724 0.626 Find similar Compare side-by-side
121788 VENTUREBEAT 2019-2-14:
Amazon cancels New York HQ2 plans
0.985 0.624 Find similar Compare side-by-side
121894 THEVERGE 2019-2-14:
Amazon cancels HQ2 in New York after backlash
0.961 0.605 Find similar Compare side-by-side
122097 VENTUREBEAT 2019-2-15:
ProBeat: Tech company expansions need to be less arrogant and more transparent
0.168 0.603 Find similar Compare side-by-side
121813 VENTUREBEAT 2019-2-14:
Amazon only has itself to blame for its failed New York campus
0.981 0.602 Find similar Compare side-by-side
121864 ENGADGET 2019-2-14:
Amazon won't build its HQ2 in NYC after all
0.744 0.566 Find similar Compare side-by-side
121809 THEVERGE 2019-2-14:
Amazon HQ2 defeat is a win for Queens activists but a ‘facepalm’ for tech leaders
0.798 0.562 Find similar Compare side-by-side
121984 TECHCRUNCH 2019-2-14:
Amazon drops plans for New York HQ2
0.952 0.554 Find similar Compare side-by-side
121805 TECHCRUNCH 2019-2-14:
New York politicians slam Amazon as it drops HQ2 plan
0.942 0.548 Find similar Compare side-by-side
121487 TECHCRUNCH 2019-2-11:
Mayor Bill de Blasio says bringing Amazon HQ2 to New York City is “mission critical”
0.540 Find similar Compare side-by-side
122198 ENGADGET 2019-2-16:
Amazon’s HQ2 New York plans didn’t need to end this way
0.235 0.540 Find similar Compare side-by-side
121871 TECHCRUNCH 2019-2-14:
Boston and NY share high-tech losses as GE and Amazon bail on same day
0.554 0.530 Find similar Compare side-by-side
121880 ARSTECHNICA 2019-2-14:
Facing opposition, Amazon scraps New York HQ2 plans
0.942 0.496 Find similar Compare side-by-side
122064 THEVERGE 2019-2-15:
What Amazon got wrong about New York City
0.529 0.464 Find similar Compare side-by-side
122143 TECHCRUNCH 2019-2-15:
As GE and Amazon move on, Google expands presence in Boston and NYC
0.023 0.461 Find similar Compare side-by-side
122203 THEVERGE 2019-2-16:
Google is reportedly hiding behind shell companies to scoop up tax breaks and land
0.018 0.453 Find similar Compare side-by-side
122013 THEVERGE 2019-2-15:
How New Yorkers beat Amazon in the HQ2 fight
0.415 0.451 Find similar Compare side-by-side
121839 TECHCRUNCH 2019-2-14:
Amazon’s NYC educational investments will continue, despite cancellation of New York HQ2
0.869 0.435 Find similar Compare side-by-side
121679 THEVERGE 2019-2-13:
Google’s 2019 expansion plans will put offices in 24 out of 50 states
0.018 0.412 Find similar Compare side-by-side
122085 TECHCRUNCH 2019-2-15:
Urban unicorn renewal
0.410 Find similar Compare side-by-side
122040 THEVERGE 2019-2-15:
Uber sues to overturn New York City’s cap on new ride-hail drivers
0.400 Find similar Compare side-by-side
122022 TECHCRUNCH 2019-2-15:
Daily Crunch: Amazon scraps HQ2 plans in NYC
0.388 Find similar Compare side-by-side
122005 VENTUREBEAT 2019-2-15:
Documents show how Google used shell companies to keep datacenter negotiations quiet
0.385 Find similar Compare side-by-side
121794 TECHREPUBLIC 2019-2-14:
How smart cities can create a road map to reduce risk and improve resiliency
0.355 Find similar Compare side-by-side

1

ID: 121876

URL: https://techcrunch.com/2019/02/14/did-new-york-lose-anything-with-amazons-rejection-its-complicated/

Date: 2019-02-14

Did New York lose anything with Amazon’s rejection? It’s complicated.

Now that Amazon has said that its taking its ball and going home rather than deal with mean, pushy New Yorkers, outside observers are giving off the sense that the city (and its local politicians) are losing out for their recalcitrance. Theyre wrong. New York City is running at about a 4.3 percent unemployment rate — higher than the national average of 3.9 percent, but a respectable number for jobs. Amazons promise of 25,000 jobs (high-paying jobs) may have reduced that number, but theres no guarantee that those jobs would be filled by New Yorkers or Queens residents more specifically — and every indication that they would have gone to Amazon employees coming from somewhere else. Remember, Amazon employees were buying real estate in Queens before the deal was even announced. The response that New Yorkers are idiots for not giving Amazon (one of the most valuable companies in the world) billions in tax incentives to build an office tower in one of its boroughs is another sign of how the country privileges business interests above civic ones. new york city is such a valuable and desirable place to do business that literally no company on earth can resist coming here which is why we were forced to bribe amazon is a curious argument for the governor to keep makingThere are things that New York can do to boost its local economy without giving away the store to Amazon. There are incentives that could go to businesses already in New York to establish offices in Queens. More importantly, local Queens residents had legitimate concerns about how their neighborhood would be transformed by Amazons entrance into the borough. Thats not to say that local politicians may not have overplayed their hand. New York local politics is no stranger to graft, corruption, shakedowns or funny business (I wasnt in the room for the negotiations), but its safe to say that mistakes were made on both sides. In the long run, Amazon would have been a benefit to the New York economy — and had the companys executives made a good-faith effort to listen to the concerns of local residents, perhaps it could have come out looking like a winner. Because there are legitimate reasons to expect Amazon to be a benefit to the New York economy. As Noah Smith wrote in Bloomberg after the deal was announced: Amazon will pay property tax on its new Long Island City offices. It will pay corporate tax — not just on its profits, but on its capital base. Its employees, especially highly paid ones, will pay the citys personal income tax. Those taxes, of course, will be somewhat offset by the incentives that the city has promised the company — up to $2 billion, depending on how many people the company hires and how many facilities it builds. Those incentives were a wasteful way to attract corporate investment. But in the long run, the tax revenue New York City gets from HQ2 will probably far exceed the cost. And thats not even taking into account Amazons effect on surrounding businesses and property values. Other technology companies will want to move to Queens now that Amazon is there. Their employees will spend their money locally, buying everything from lattes to MRIs.  Some estimates place HQ2s local economic boost at $17 billion a year. Even dividing that in half, and even assuming that the estimate is optimistic by a factor of 2 or 3, it seems likely that the economic benefit Queens reaps from HQ2 will quickly exceed the upfront cost — unlike, say, Wisconsins ill-advised Foxconn factory. Those benefits are true, but harder to quantify for a city like New York when taken against the impact those jobs and spending would have on the fabric of the local economy and the housing, transit and government services that new residents would demand. The livability crisis thats currently afflicting Seattle and San Francisco is evidence of how cities need to be careful what they wish for when it comes to the explosive growth of technology companies (and the attendant wealth that comes with it) in their metropolises. In any event, the urban landscape of the U.S. is being radically reshaped by technology companies — creating cities that are haves and have-nots much as technology has bifurcated the national economy into digital haves and have nots. As Mark Muro and Robert Maxim of the Brookings Institute noted in this piece for US News and World Report: Scholars have for years suspected that tech might alter the hierarchy of cities, given its bias toward skilled workers. More than a decade ago, researchers Paul Beaudry, Mark Doms and Ethan G. Lewis showed cities that adopted personal computers earliest and fastest saw their relative wages increase the quickest. Now, there is more evidence – including in our own work – that digital technologies are contributing heavily to the divergence of metro economies and the pull away of superstar cities like Boston and San Francisco from more ordinary ones, with painful impacts. Recently, Princeton economist Elisa Giannone demonstrated that the divergence of cities wages since 1980 – after decades of convergence – reflects a mix of technologys increased rewards to highly skilled tech workers and tech-driven industry clustering. Likewise, Brookings research has shown that a short list of highly digital, often coastal tech hubs is growing even more digital and pulling farther away from the pack on measures of growth and income. What we call the digitization of everything is in this way exacerbating the unevenness of Americas economic landscape. Its far easier to make the case that Amazons decision to set up regional offices in Nashville will have far more positive outcomes for that city. But making American cities compete beauty pageant-style and bend over backwards to appease a multi-billion-dollar corporation is pretty gross — and a poor read of national sentiment around the roles that technology companies play in modern American society. As an example of how to expand in a city without invoking the wrath of the local community, observers need only look at how Google is expanding in New York. The company is planning to add 14,000 jobs in the city and has committed to $1 billion in spending to upgrade its West side campuses. Ostensibly, Google is expanding its presence in New York to compete for the talent it sees coming from the city (or coming to the city) and because New York is strategically important. Amazons decision to forsake New York means that its losing access to that talent and creating opportunities for other tech companies to come in and take its place — or for local companies to retain their edge. Heres hoping that New Yorks local tech community can supply Queens with those 25,000 jobs by building the next Amazon — and working with the community to do it. These days it seems like Democracy is a religion thats replaced God with money. The pushback against Amazon shows that New York at least is adding civic responsibility into that equation somewhere.